I’d go with the chocolate chip, Andy
When you’re the world’s #2 player (with a Scottish accent) it’s kinda hard to go undercover in tennis-crazed Mason, Ohio. But that’s just what Andy Murray did earlier this week at the Western & Southern Open tournament, just north of Cincinnati. He decided to take a quick shift at the Graeter’s ice cream booth in the tourney food court. (I was the stadium PA announcer for several years back in the day, so I have fond memories of it, back when it was titled the “Thriftway ATP Championships.”)
And I have had more than a little Graeter’s in my time. Totally recommend the Chocolate Chip and the Peach. Drop-dead awesome.